“Do not let your left hand know what your right hand is doing,”- Matthew 6:3 is probably one of the common bible quotes heard once the conversation behind giving behind closed doors comes up.
Giving is one of the most beautiful acts of kindness we can offer to others. Whether it’s donating money, volunteering time, or simply lending a hand, generosity has the power to transform lives. But when it comes to how we give, there’s a long-standing debate: should giving be done quietly and privately, or is it okay to give openly and publicly?
The Case for Giving in Private
Many spiritual and cultural traditions emphasize giving in secret. The idea is simple, generosity isn’t about praise or recognition, but about genuine care and compassion. Many traditions and spiritual teachings emphasize the value of giving quietly. When generosity is done behind closed doors, it preserves humility and selflessness. Without an audience, giving becomes an intimate act. A pure expression of care without the distraction of recognition or praise. The talk of dignity and privacy of those receiving help also comes to play. Yes, not everyone will feel comfortable having their struggles or pain broadcasted for all to see. Giving behind closed doors may then be a best alternative to preserve their sense of respect.
But does this make Public Good wrong?
Many public acts of generosity begin by shining a light on the unseen struggles of individuals or communities. Bringing these hidden challenges into the open raises awareness and invites compassion. This call to action creates a powerful ripple effect, inspiring donations, support, and collective efforts from many to help ease those burdens. In turning private pain into shared concern, public giving becomes a beacon of hope and solidarity.
“Transparency can build trust“. is a strong mantra which shouldn’t be overlooked in the discussion of public good. When donors share how and where their support is going, it reassures others about the effectiveness and honesty of charitable work, encouraging more people to get involved. Public acts of generosity can also be a catalyst. One that inspires others to join in, creating the effect of kindness and support. When people see others giving, it can motivate them to do the same, multiplying the impact far beyond one individual.
Ultimately, there’s no one-size-fits-all rule for giving. It’s a deeply personal decision shaped by individual values, context, and intentions. When deciding how to give, it’s helpful to ask yourself:
- Why am I giving — for genuine kindness, or recognition?
- How might my giving affect the privacy and dignity of the recipient?
- Could sharing my act of giving help inspire others or raise awareness?
- Am I comfortable with my generosity being public?
Recognizing that generosity takes many forms allows each of us to find a balance that feels right. Some gifts are best kept quiet, while others shine brighter when shared.
The Heart of Giving
At the end of the day, the true power of giving lies not in whether it’s done in private or public, but in the spirit behind it. When generosity comes from a place of genuine care, kindness, and respect, it can transform lives no matter who sees it.
So whether you choose to give behind closed doors or out in the open, remember that your intention and the impact you create are what truly matter.